BSO COLD CASE HOMICIDE DETECTIVES LINK TWO SUSPECTS TO 2007 MURDER
| PIO Number | 26-10-17 | Date | Oct. 15, 2026 |
MEDIA NOTE: To view the video above, click on the play button. To see a version without captions and music, click HERE. For a version without music and captions, click HERE.
On May 13, 2007, Leon Heron, 34, headed home to his wife at their Lauderdale Lakes apartment with dinner from Taco Bell. He would never make it inside.
As Heron walked toward his apartment, two subjects intent on robbery, confronted him and demanded his property. Heron fought back and endured a struggle with his attackers. Eventually, one of the attackers pulled a gun and shot Heron, killing him.
For nearly 20 years, Heron’s homicide case was unsolved. Until now.
In April 2023, Broward Sheriff’s Office Cold Case Homicide Unit Detective David Towsley received information that a Florida prison inmate had information about a Broward County murder. Towsley met with the inmate, Brittany Hanfield, who claimed she was a witness to the killing and provided vague details. With further investigation, Detective Towsley learned that the homicide was Heron’s and pressed Hanfield for more information.
“What she told me was ultimately what it ended up being was two 17-year-old young ladies who were out driving round Broward County in a stolen SUV looking for somebody to rob,” Detective Towsley said.
But there was another wrinkle – the investigation revealed that Hanfield was not a witness, but a participant. Eventually, the investigation would lead to the second suspect – Sheila Arstil. Both women are now charged with first degree murder and, according to Detective Towsley, the evidence against them is strong.
“We have the DNA which puts them there. We’ve got their confessions,” Detective Towsley.
Hanfield was arrested on a first-degree murder charge on Nov. 10, 2025, and a Broward County Grand Jury indicted Arstil on a charge of first-degree murder on Oct. 7, 2026. But beyond arresting the two women, Detective Towsley feels tremendous satisfaction in finally providing answers to Leon Heron’s mother.
“His mother was so grateful to get this information, to know finally what happened to her son,” Detective Towsley explained. “She loves her son like nobody would believe, and all of these years, it’s been eating at her soul, as to what happened to him. Why was he targeted? Why was he killed? So, I was very happy to bring her that information.”
And this case also serves as another reminder of the success and commitment of the BSO Cold Case Homicide Unit.
“These cases are long overdue,” Detective Towsley said. “As (Sheriff Dr. Gregory Tony) always says, ‘justice has no expiration date.’ And that’s the motto we live on every day.”
Homicide Det. D. Towsley, BSO CID
Homicide Sgt. P. Reynolds, BSO CID
Lauderdale Lakes
BSO Crime Lab
BSO Crime Scene
Carey Codd/Sr. PIO
Gerdy St. Louis/PIO