PIO Number: 18-6-3 

BSO Case Number: 07-1805-003342 & 10-1805-004833

Date: May 31, 2018

Time: 8:39 a.m. & 10:33 a.m.

Jurisdiction: Tamarac & Deerfield Beach

Place of Occurrence: 4400 block of Rock Island Rd., Tamarac & 4600 block of S.W. 10th St., Deerfield Beach

Tamarac Crash Driver: Matthew J. Scully, 31, male, 4/24/1987, 3196 N. Jog Road, West Palm Beach (DECEASED)

Deerfield Crash Driver 1: Kristina I. Garcia, 20, female, 10/20/97, 908 Belfry Drive S., West Palm Beach (DECEASED)

Deerfield Crash Driver 2: Elaine M. Gallman, 51, female, Lighthouse Point (HOSPITALIZED)

Description of Incident:

Traffic homicide detectives are investigating two deadly crashes from May 31. In each case, failure to maintain control of the vehicle is considered a primary factor.

Just after 8:30 a.m., Matthew J. Scully was driving a 2003 Honda Accord southbound on Rock Island Road in Tamarac. Scully was traveling above the posted 40 mph speed limit. For an unknown reason, Scully lost control of his vehicle, struck the raised curb and rotated clockwise where it collided with a concrete light pole.

The impact caused severe damage to the driver's side as it wrapped around the pole. Scully was pronounced dead at the scene. Excessive speed, failure to maintain control of the vehicle and suspected impairment are all considered factors in this case.

At approximately 10:30 a.m. Kristina Garcia was driving a 2002 Toyota Tacoma Pickup eastbound on S.W. 10th Street in the 4600 block in Deerfield Beach when it struck the inside raised curb. Garcia's car then crossed the center grass median and struck a storm drain.

Elaine Gallman was driving a 2013 Nissan Pathfinder westbound on S.W. 10th Street when Garcia's car entered her car's path while airborne. BSO Fire Rescue extricated Gallman and her passenger and transported them to Broward Health North for treatment.

The preliminary cause of the crash at this time appears to be Garcia's inability to remain in control of her truck.  

Dets. A. Morales & D. Huneke, THI
Tamarac & Deerfield Beach

Gina Carter/PIO
6/4/18   1300

Search The Site

Contact Us

Broward's Sheriff's Office
2601 West Broward Boulevard
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33312

Dial 911 for Emergencies Only

Non-Emergencies (954) 764-HELP (4357)

To report a crime tip (954) 493-TIPS (8477)

To report abuse (800) 96-ABUSE (22873)

General Information (954) 765-4321

Privacy Policy - Under Florida law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public-records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by phone or in writing.

Terms of Use - © 2018 Broward County Sheriff's Office.
All rights reserved. This information is made available to the public and law enforcement in the interest of public safety. Any unauthorized use of this information is forbidden and subject to criminal prosecution.

Accessibility Policy

Social Terms of Use - The Broward Sheriff’s Office (“Agency”) Social Media Terms of Use establishes guidelines for Agency- maintained social media sites, pages and posts on social media networks, including but not limited to Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and YouTube.